Throughout the duration of the dispute between New Jersey Transit and the employees who keep the trains running, the Lackawanna Coalition has consistently expressed its hope that both sides would reach an agreement, and that the trains would continue to take riders to their destinations safely and comfortably. We are delighted that, indeed, such an agreement has been reached and that the trains will continue to run.

We know the people on both sides of the bargaining table, and we appreciate their efforts in keeping negotiations going, until they reached a successful conclusion. We express our appreciation also to our Online Editor John Bobsin for posting the news on this site, and we hope we have kept you well-informed, from the view of the people who are always advocating for your mobility.

There is still more to be done to improve our trains, but now we will be able to move forward in an atmosphere of peace between labor and management. We remain as committed as ever to better transit for all riders in the region, and we always want to know what we can do to help improve your transit, whether you have an automobile and choose to use it, or you depend on it for all of your mobility.

Before a tentative agreement was reached (see above) to avoid a threatened March 13 strike, NJ Transit said they were taking steps for an orderly shutdown of the rail system, although NJT said that the steps would be 'largely invislbe' to the public. Despite early optimism that a settlement might be forthcoming by Thursday, talks adjourned without any resolution, according to reporting by Larry Higgs for nj.com.  WNYC Radio reported that the talks ended on a "sour note," after NJ Transit apparently sent a notice to the employees to the effect that health care benefits would be suspended in case of a strike; NJT said such a notice was required by federal law. Union spokesperson Steve Burkert said "We object to NJT's conduct in this matter while the parties are fully engaged in the negotiation process."   Reporting by Andy Newman and Emma G. Fitzsimmons in the New York Times (March 10) covered employers' arrangements in case of a strike: altered work hours and locations, work-at-home, and even emergency sleepover rooms. The negotiating teams will return to the table at 10 a.m. on Friday. Union spokesperson  Burkert had earlier said that a strike on Sunday, after the federally-mandated cooling-off period expires, is not mandatory. A management lockout is also possible, but NJT interim executive director Dennis Martin has said that NJT does not plan to lock out its employees.  A main sticking point in the negotiations has been how much employees will pay for their health insurance; the union wants to limit employee contributions to 2.5% of the total premiums, which is said to be typical at other commuter railroads; NJT wants the workers to pay 10-20% of the premiums.

The impact of a strike, which could start on Sunday, could be severe. The Partnership for New York, a business group, estimated that every hour employees are delayed getting to work would cost $5.9 million, saying "A transit strike is among the most expensive events that can happen to New York City."  Transportation consultant Sam Schwartz predicted traffic jams of up to 23 miles on highways leading to Manhattan.  NJ Transit itself predicted increased travel times of an hour or more in the alternate transportation schemes it has arranged, involving park-and-ride with buses to ferries or the PATH transit system, which would continue to operate, and even the alternate schemes would only handle a fraction of the regular passenger load; the alternatives are only for peak hour commuters. Some local communities announced their own alternative bus services to Manhattan for stranded commuters, including Morristown and Morris Township; each will charge $25, cash only, and buses will leave when full, starting at 5 a.m. at the Morristown station and 6 a.m. at Convent Station.  The service at Convent Station requires that riders hold a monthly parking pass at that station.  Metro-North Railroad service west of Suffern will also be suspended in the case of a strike; Metro-North announced that bus service for their riders will operate from Harriman and Middletown.

New Jersey Transit announced its contingency plans today, if a strike or lockout should halt all NJT rail service beginning Sunday, March 13th. While all train riders in North and Central New Jersey will feel the pain, our primary lines of concern will be among the hardest-hit. There are few bus routes on NJT that run from points along our lines to New York City, and the NJT and privately-operated bus routs in the area will not be able to accommodate most of the riders who now take the train. Some places on the lines have buses to Newark and other localities, but these buses will not be able to absorb many of the train riders, either.

There will be enhanced service on certain bus routes, and the primary change is that there will be four temporary park-and-ride bus services: Ramsey-Route 17 Station to the Port Imperial Ferry in Weehawken, Metropark Station to Harrison for connection with PATH trains, Hamilton Station to Newark Penn Station and a shuttle bus between Met Life Stadium in the Meadowlands and Port Auithority Bus Terminal. Academy Bus will also serve a park-and-ride lot in Monmouth County. These services will operate only during weekday peak-commuting hours, and only in the direction going toward New York City.

It is difficult to blame NJT management for this schedule, even though it offers very little for riders on the Morris & Essex, Montclair-Boonton or Gladstone Lines. The Port Authority Bus Terminal is crowded to capacity at peak-commuting times, and there is little room for extra buses. The highways will also be clogged with motorists who commute by train. The situation will be difficult for motorists, and people who depend on transit will have very little mobility.

Read more: Morristown, Montclair-Boonton, and Gladsone Lines will be Hard Hit if There is a Strike

NJ Transit shut down service before the blizzard struck on Saturday, Jan. 23, which meant that the Garden State had essentially no public transportation until service came back over the next three days. Did management make the right decision?

John Bobsin, our Online Editor and former Vice-Chair, says YES:

As the blizzard of Jan. 23 bore down on the Northeast, no one could say it was a surprise: TV weather forecasters had accurately predicted the course of the storm for days. Of course, there was always the element of uncertainty: what if it goes out to sea? With the clock ticking, transit managers faced the usual, unenviable decision: tough it out and keep running, or take the safe course and shut down operations, risking media opprobrium should the storm prove a bust.

Read more: Point/Counterpoint: Reflecting on NJT’s Blizzard Decision — Was it the Right Choice?

We may lose our trains very soon. After five years without a contract, NJ Transit’s rail workers could walk off the job, or management could lock them out. On Sunday, March 13, and maybe for a long time after that, the only trains in New Jersey besides light rail, PATH or PATCO in South Jersey, could be Amtrak trains running between New York Penn Station and points far beyond Trenton.

That would cause an economic catastrophe for the region; only short of the devastation that a work stoppage on the New York City transit system would trigger. Motorists would still have mobility, at least in theory, but the roads would be clogged. Bus riders would face the same problem, along with the additional burden of rail riders attempting to crowd onto the buses. Whatever contingency plans that NJ Transit might implement would do little to alleviate the overall loss of mobility. Their plan to run commuter buses form temporary park-and-ride lots would do little to help motorists who could get to those facilities, and absolutely nothing for people who depend on transit, without access to an automobile. People who depend on transit will suffer more than anyone else; they will be stuck.

It is absolutely essential that cooler heads prevail, and a work stoppage does not occur. People who depend on transit are being used as unwilling pawns in a monetary chess game being played by politicians who have access to automobiles and do not need to ride transit. The Republican Christie Administration and the Democrat-controlled Legislature have literally decimated support for transit; cutting it by 90% since the Christie Administration took office. It is easy to understand why NJT management says they cannot afford a labor settlement like the ones recommended by the Presidential Emergency Boards. That does not get us to where we need to go, however. We, the riders, do not need political posturing. However the details are worked out, we need our trains.

A little under two weeks from now – Sunday March 13 – could be the beginning of a strike by New Jersey Transit’s rail employees. Although public transit alternatives for the Coalition’s lines of concern will be very limited in that event, we’ll look at what the possibilities are.

Let’s be clear that none of the alternative routes discussed here will be able to carry more than a tiny fraction of the people currently riding the trains. NJ Transit is estimating that its buses can handle less than 40% of the riders going into New York alone.

Read more: Updated: Your Morris & Essex/Montclair Boonton Strike Survival Guide

NJ Transit plans to extend the capability of its My Tix smartphone application, which has grown rapidly in use on rail lines, to single-ride bus tickets, starting March 16 on selected bus lines. In a phased rollout, one-way tickets on light rail lines would soon follow.  Until now, only monthly passes for bus and light rail lines can be purchased with the application.  The smartphone apps have sold 12 million tickets since debuting in 2013. NJT also said it was exploring other payment options, such as Apple Pay, and said it has installed new cellphone charging stations in New York's Penn Station and in NJT's Hoboken terminal. The new developments were reported by Larry Higgs on nj.com; see his story here.

If New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio has his way, 16 miles along the east side of the East River will have a streetcar line linking Queens and Brooklyn.  The proposed line, dubbed the "Brooklyn-Queens Connector," would cost an estimated $2.5 billion, and would extend from Astoria in Queens to Sunset Park in Brooklyn, providing transit connectivity to a rapidly-growing area not well served by the city's subway system, built many decades ago.  The Mayor was set to propose the new line in his State of the City speech, scheduled for February 4, according to reporting by Michael M. Grynbaum in the New York Times (Feb. 4). The proposal would add the city to an increasing list of cities that have embraced surface rail transit systems, including Newark and the Hudson County waterfront in nearby New Jersey, but previous attempts to build streetcar systems in New York City, notably in Red Hook, Brooklyn, and along 42 Street in Manhattan, have not moved forward. The proposal is a departure from the Mayor's previous stance on transportation, not seen as mass-transit oriented. The plan can expect spirited discussion in neighborhoods it will traverse, and support from real estate developers along the line.

A Times editorial (Feb. 5) provided a mixed review of the plan, wondering if better bus service might not be a cheaper solution, and concluding that implementing the plan "will have to survive the inevitable criticism of urbanites who think they know better ways than a trolley car to get around New York."

Read the complete story here.

On Tuesday, January 26, all NJT services were finally operating with a semblance of normalcy, roughly 75 hours after systemwide services were suspended at the close of service Friday night, Jan. 22, in anticipation of the big blizzard that struck the area on Saturday, Jan. 23.  Most NJT services returned on Monday, but the Gladstone Branch rail service remained suspended until Tuesday morning.  Elsewhere in the New York area, the Long Island Rail Road also returned to full service on Tuesday; a number of branches of the LIRR were unable to operate on Monday, although the major LIRR lines did return to service. By Tuesday, the only major service in the area not yet operating was the PATH rapid transit system, which remained suspended between Jersey City and Newark; by noon Tuesday, PATH had announced plans for full sevice in the evening rush hour. NJ Transit had "led the way" in suspending service, announcing early that no trains or buses would run after the close of service on Friday night. Other railroads in the New York area tried to keep running but eventually shut down during the storm; underground services on the New York subways continued. On Sunday morning, NJ Governor Chris Christie told media that the state had weathered the storm "remarkably well," and said that bus and light rail service would return by noon Sunday, with the regular rail system also "shooting for" service at noon.  NJT's own website was silent on its plans until later in the morning, eventually announcing that rail service would start to return at noon, "beginning with the light rail" system.Trains did start to run on several lines, including Morris & Essex service between New York and Dover; the weekend service from Hoboken to Bay Street Montclair; on the Main/Bergen/Pascack lines; and on the Northeast Corridor to and from Trenton. But other lines lagged, and eventually NJT conceded that there would be no service Sunday on the Gladstone Branch, the Raritan Valley Line, or the North Jersey Coast Line. Finally, on Monday morning, all trains were said to be coming back, with the notable exception of the Gladstone Branch, where substitute bus service was to be offered; private bus operators along the Gladstone were to be cross-honoring NJT rail passes. On other suburban rail lines, Metro-North had the best service, with all lines returning to normal during the afternoon on Sunday.  Long Island Rail Road was able to restore many of its lines on Sunday, but no trains were running on several branches; as of Monday service on the Port Washington, Hempstead, West Hempstead, and Long Beach lines remained suspended, as was Montauk service east of Speonk; there was also no service to Atlantic Terminal in Brooklyn. Media reported a rocky start to LIRR service on Monday, and said that service started at 7 a.m. instead of 5 a.m., with many trains packed and riders worrying about the evening return ride.  By Monday morning, all NYC Transit subway lines appeared to be operating; a number of above-surface lines had been suspended on Sunday, as was the Staten Island Railway, which was also back on Monday, albeit with delays.

In a move that may set a precedent for future winter storms, NJ Transit shut down of its rail, bus, and light rail services early Saturday morning in anticipation of Winter Storm Jonas.

According to their website, NJ Transit rail service should “resume when conditions permit and when mandatory federal inspections can be completed.” As of 12 PM no timeline for this has been released. However in past years NJ Transit had indicated that “it takes at least 12 hours to restore rail service once it has been suspended,” pegging reopening at 2 PM at the earliest.

Prudent or a Dangerous Decision?

Shutting down has some obvious benefits. It reduces the chances of a train being stranded if the storm causes some part of the railroad’s infrastructure to fail. Downed trees can knock down the overhead wires that power trains on NJ Transit lines. Power failures may shut off the signal system, forcing trains to limp along at heavily restricted speeds. Downed trees can block the railroad. And the condition of the roads can make it unsafe for train crew members to drive to their sign-on points as they normally would (though having crews come in prior to the storm and sleep at major terminals such as Hoboken can mitigate this last risk).

However there are also some major problems. As noted above, heavy inspections are required to resume service after it has been shut down. And the absence of rail service eliminates what is often the safest travel available during extreme winter weather.

Read more: NJ Transit Shuts Down Completely For January 23rd Blizzard: Our Reaction